To join or not to join? Norway is edging closer to the EU

[LToremark]

To join or not to join? Norway is edging closer to the EU

To join or not to join? Norway is edging closer to the EU
Expert comment
LToremark
11 April 2025

Trump's trade war has brought Norway even closer to the EU and increased the urgency for it to make a decision about membership.



Norway is facing a similar challenge to its long-term policy of remaining outside the EU as Finland and Sweden did with their stance on NATO membership three years ago.  

Finland and Sweden's foreign and security policies were for decades based on the idea that the Russian threat was manageable. But Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022 posed a massive challenge to Finland and Sweden's policy of remaining outside NATO . 



Related content
Keeping the peace on NATO's longest border with Russia

From a Finnish and Swedish perspective, the fact that Ukraine was not a NATO member was an important factor. Helsinki especially saw clearly that any self-imposed restrictions for the sake of good relations with Russia would not be respected and thus not guarantee safety.

In the case of Norway, its foreign and security policy has since the end of the Second World War been based on the assumption that its relationship with the US  and membership of NATO will guarantee its security. But the example of Norway's neighbour Denmark – both a NATO and EU  member – makes it clear that previously close relations with the US do not guarantee future US commitment to any European country's security. 

Denmark has been one of the most loyal European allies to the US, fighting alongside American forces in Iraq and Afghanistan and sustaining the highest killed in action ratio  per capita. But that has not stopped President Trump from issuing repeated threats to annex Greenland from Denmark, by military means if necessary , or Vice President Vance from stating that Denmark 'has not been a good ally '.
Even the closest possible partner is still not a member
Much like Finland and Sweden's NATO policy prior to accession, Norway has chosen the closest possible integration with the EU short of membership. As a result, Norway aligns most of its regulation, trade and foreign policy with the EU, joins EU sanctions, and as an EEA/EFTA member pays into the EU budget  for the programmes and agencies it wants to participate in. 

But so far Norway does not have a seat at the table where decisions affecting Norway are made – an arrangement which in January 2025 caused Norway's government to collapse over the adoption of the EU's energy rules. At the moment, Norway's government is trying to prevent the country from getting caught in the crossfire of EU–US tariffs. 



Related content
Sweden brings benefits for NATO but accession delay raises difficult questions

Just like Finland and Sweden with NATO, Norway is realizing that even the closest possible partnership with the EU is not the same as membership. 

Accordingly, support for EU membership has risen considerably in Norway over the past months, reaching 41 per cent in a recent poll . In 2023, the 'yes' side still only accounted for 27 per cent . While the 'no' side still leads with 48 per cent, 63 per cent of respondents were positive towards a new referendum on EU membership – in contrast to the Norwegian political leadership that has ruled out a renewed EU debate . The new government in Iceland, the other non-EU Nordic country, has promised a referendum on EU membership no later than 2027  – a development that Norway is watching closely.  

In Finland and Sweden, opinion polls showed that opposition to NATO membership was stable for decades until the full-scale invasion of Ukraine tipped the scales overnight. There too, politicians were behind the curve and had to catch up fast.

Economically, Norway has done well without EU membership, due to its abundant natural resources. Since Russia's invasion of Ukraine, it has become Europe's most important gas supplier and reaped massive windfall profits , bringing the Norwegian sovereign wealth fund to a record 20 trillion NOK in 2024  ($1.8 trillion). 

But while the single market is the centrepiece of the EU, it is not the only rationale for joining the union. Norway's neighbour Finland, for example, joined the EU mainly for security reasons  to improve its relative position vis-à-vis Russia. Finland was also the only Nordic country to join the Eurozone , to have a seat at the table in a core area of European integration. Today, Ukraine's integration into the EU has become a question of the highest geopolitical importance.
Less US means more EU
As the US considers scaling down its presence in Europe  and with its commitment to NATO thrown into question, a new European security architecture is beginning to take shape. Inclusion and exclusion in this new security order, as well as possible grey zones, may no longer be delineated by NATO membership, but rather along the borders of the EU. 


Source: https://www.chathamhouse.org/2025/04/join-or-not-join-norway-edging-closer-eu Apr 11, 2025, 07:49 AM